Workday says millions of job applicants can't sue as a group over AI screening
By Daniel Wiessner
Nov 11 (Reuters) - Workday has asked a US judge to reject a bid to allow potentially millions of job applicants to pursue discrimination claims against the company as a group over its AI-powered screening software used by hundreds of employers.
Workday in a filing in San Francisco federal court late Tuesday said the four named plaintiffs in the 2023 lawsuit have not shown that the company made any hiring decisions on behalf of its customers, so there is no common evidence that would allow the proposed classes alleging race, sex, age and disability discrimination to be certified.
"The question is not whether Plaintiffs raise common questions, but whether a classwide proceeding can generate common answers," the company said in the filing.
In a separate filing making similar arguments, Workday also asked US District Judge Rita Lin to decertify a conditional collective of more than 15,000 people who have opted into the lawsuit to allege age discrimination. Unlike other federal laws at issue in the case, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act allows for conditional certification so potential class members can be notified of a lawsuit and opt into it.
Lawyers for the named plaintiffs in the 2023 lawsuit did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Wednesday.
Lin is scheduled to hold a hearing on class certification in March.
The lawsuit is the first of its kind to broadly target the algorithmic decision-making underpinning AI screening software that has become very common among large employers, and could help shape how such litigation is conducted.
Government agencies and worker advocates have expressed concerns that AI tools can discriminate against job applicants when they are built using data that reflects existing biases. But there has been little litigation so far over employers' use of the tools, which experts have said could be due to many job applicants not knowing when employers use AI software.
Workday in Tuesday's filing said that more than 11,500 organizations use its software to manage business functions such as human resources, payroll and procurement.
The lawsuit involves three separate features of Workday software, including one that compares the skills on an applicant's resume to those in a job posting and that Workday says most of its customers never utilized. The other features grade how well an application matches a job posting and search a company's own database for past applicants to suggest for current openings.
Lin rejected the company's initial attempts to dismiss the case in 2024, and in June mostly denied the company's bid to toss out amendments to the lawsuit alleging violations of California law.
Workday has said its technology only looks at job qualifications and not protected traits such as race or age, and that its products are rigorously tested to identify any potential bias.
The case is Mobley v. Workday Inc, US District Court for the Northern District of California, No. 3:23-cv-00770.
For Mobley: Lee Winston and Roderick Cooks of Winston Cooks
For Workday: Julie Totten, Kayla Grundy and Erin Connell of Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe
Read more:
Workday must face California lawsuit over AI bias in job screening tools
Workday will likely face California claims in sprawling AI bias lawsuit
Workday must face novel bias lawsuit over AI screening software
Tutoring firm settles US agency's first bias lawsuit involving AI software