Czech central bank November 5 board meeting minutes

By Reuters News

- Following is the full text of the minutes from the Czech National Bank's (CNB) November 5 monetary policy meeting, released on Friday:


The meeting opened with a presentation of the seventh situation report and the new macroeconomic forecast. According to this forecast, inflation would temporarily increase at the beginning of the coming year but would then start to decline thanks to tight monetary policy and return to close to the 2% target in early 2028. Consistent with the baseline scenario of the forecast was a rise in short-term market interest rates.

The Bank Board assessed the risks and uncertainties of the outlook for the fulfilment of the inflation target as inflationary overall. Aleš Michl said that the CNB is here to ensure that the koruna holds its value and that it pays to work and save. Inflation is always about money and debt. Once it starts to spiral upwards, it is costly and takes a lot of time to rein it in. So let’s not allow it to spiral upwards again. Through our actions, we show that Czechs should expect a low-inflation environment in the long term.

A large part of the Board’s discussion concerned the ongoing energy shock and its pass-through to domestic inflation. There was a consensus that domestic demand was resilient for now and there were no visible signs of a cooling due to the higher energy prices. At the same time, the second-round effects of this shock had not shown up significantly in domestic inflation so far. As the conflict dragged on, however, it was increasingly likely that they would do so. In this regard, Jakub Seidler noted that the rise in energy prices had been going for so long and was so pronounced that second-round effects would be hard to avoid and the current monetary policy stance was therefore only affecting its magnitude, or rather the time it would take for these effects to fade out from inflation. Eva Zamrazilová considered the potential future course of the conflict, including in the context of the US congressional elections. In her opinion, if the conflict were to end soon, it would not be necessary to raise rates at the current meeting, given the current absence of second-round effects of the energy shock. On the other hand, if the conflict were to drag on, fuel prices and other energy prices would probably pass through to core inflation. Karina Kubelková agreed. In her opinion, the key question was whether this was a shock that would gradually subside, or whether we would be operating at a new normal. In the latter case, we could see alternating periods of sharp growth and decline in energy prices, but prices would remain high on average. The likelihood of such a situation was certainly not negligible. Jan Frait said that the growth in energy prices had shifted from spot prices to longer-term contracts and its effects would probably persist for some time. This was an inflationary factor. At the same time, however, energy prices could, in his view, have a negative effect on demand and economic activity through a decrease in the real income of households and firms. He also noted that the current supply shock had hit the domestic economy in a far better position than in 2022. Jan Kubíček agreed, adding that the favourable combination of factors that had helped keep inflation in the tolerance band around the target this year would nonetheless fade away next year. Jan Procházka mentioned that headline inflation and core inflation had both been a little higher than expected in September. The slight increase in goods inflation could, in his opinion, represent the first manifestation of second-round effects of the energy shock.

The board members agreed that elevated longer-term interest rates were fostering restrictive financial conditions. Credit growth remained high but was now showing some signs of slowing. In this regard, Jan Frait expressed the opinion that the global growth in long-term rates primarily reflected expectations that central banks would raise their rates in response to inflation caused by energy prices. In his opinion, however, market valuations were too high and were perhaps also being driven up by limited liquidity in some segments of the money market and by psychological factors. In the domestic economy, he could now see the growth in longer-term rates manifesting as a certain slowdown in mortgage lending, which could be expected to spill over gradually into other segments. Eva Zamrazilová also noted that long-term rates had sufficiently tightened the mortgage market, so an increase in monetary policy rates at the present meeting would not have any further significant effect on imputed rents. Jan Kubíček agreed that even though the volume of mortgages was still rising quite quickly year on year, longer-term rates were having a restrictive effect on mortgages and their rate of growth was likely to slow further. At the same time, however, he noted that credit activity had shifted to the segment of loans to non-financial corporations. Jakub Seidler added that the first signs of a slowdown in credit growth, coupled with the restrictive effect of longer-term rates, reduced the need for a major increase in monetary policy rates for the time being.

In a discussion of domestic inflation, Jan Kubíček drew attention to the repeatedly slightly higher-than-expected core inflation readings. He added that economic growth had been rather disappointing this year, even though the demand side was growing at a solid pace. Not only was core inflation currently not slowing in line with prior expectations, it was actually rising moderately. From his perspective, this combination of higher-than-expected growth in core prices and lower-than-expected economic growth was in turn exacerbating the problem of elevated core inflation. Jakub Seidler noted that, overall, producer prices indicated that price pressures were beginning to intensify, even though they were not yet visible directly in consumer inflation. Looking more broadly at domestic inflation, Eva Zamrazilová mentioned that in a low-inflation environment, inflation is dominated by changes in relative prices, whereas in a high-inflation environment, prices rise across the entire consumer basket. The present situation exhibited the characteristics of a low-inflation environment, in which it is possible to look through cost shocks.

Some of the board members also addressed the issue of inflation expectations. Karina Kubelková and Jakub Seidler said that inflation expectations were currently well anchored, but they also drew attention to the sensitivity of households’ expectations to food and energy prices, which had been falling this year but would rise next year. Jan Procházka agreed, adding that households’ inflation expectations were already showing signs of increasing.

On the subject of economic activity, Jan Procházka commented that he was still less optimistic than the forecast as regards expectations of solid economic growth driven by rising external demand. Karina Kubelková added that in Europe, the external shocks were now being joined by internal instability; this was not an environment conducive to economic growth. Jakub Seidler said that domestic demand remained robust despite the weaker overall growth of the economy. However, this was increasing the likelihood of greater pass-through of the energy shock from first-round to second-round inflationary effects, and it was this risk that monetary policy should respond to proactively. Karina Kubelková expressed the opinion that the surprising resilience of the Czech economy may be related to the fact that Czech companies had invested heavily in energy-saving measures in the past, which had made them less sensitive to energy prices. Likewise, households, too, may not be caught off guard by rising energy prices to the same extent as in 2022.

Jan Frait said that it was important to pay attention to global macro-financial developments. Although increased volatility, rather than signs of major disruption, was apparent in asset markets, he felt that current developments there were a reason to exercise some caution.

As regards the current monetary policy decision, the board members agreed that monetary policy needed to be kept relatively tight and that it could be desirable to raise interest rates modestly to limit the second-round effects of the energy shock. There were some differences in opinion on the timing of this step.

Jan Procházka said that although, for him, the current decision was trickier than usual, he considered it safer to raise rates – and hence the degree of restriction – at this meeting, given that he did not see desirable calming trends in core inflation, wage growth and lending activity. Leaving aside the strong koruna, monetary conditions had been more or less neutral recently. Eva Zamrazilová also described her current decision as a difficult one. She summarised her position by saying that she saw no second-round effects so far and that real rates would still remain positive if rates were kept unchanged, despite the projected rise in inflation. At the same time, the long end of the yield curve was delivering a modest degree of restriction, and she therefore considered it possible to leave the rate increase to the next meeting. Jan Frait said that the economy would grow more slowly this year relative to its estimated potential rate and was most probably not overheated. In his view, it was possible in such an environment to carefully consider tightening monetary policy further, to leave rates unchanged at the current meeting and to await further developments, including rate hikes by other central banks, with the CNB following their lead if that proved desirable. According to Karina Kubelková, the risks and uncertainties had increased. She therefore expressed a preference for waiting for more data and deferring the decision until December, when, among other things, the ECB and the Fed would also be making decisions. Jakub Seidler was inclined to raise rates, while emphasising that this step was not a reaction to the first-round effects of the supply shock, but rather a proactive monetary policy response to the expected second-round impacts of the current energy shock on consumer prices. Jan Kubíček was also in favour of raising rates, mainly because of core inflation, which not only was not falling, but also would probably be affected next year by the second-round effects of the shock. The board members agreed that a rate increase at this meeting would not mark the start of a new cycle of raising rates.

After discussing the situation report, the Bank Board increased the key policy rates by 0.25 percentage point. Four members voted in favour of this decision: Aleš Michl, Jan Kubíček, Jan Procházka and Jakub Seidler. Three members, Eva Zamrazilová, Jan Frait and Karina Kubelková, voted for leaving rates unchanged.

Capital.com is an execution-only brokerage platform and the content provided on the Capital.com website is intended for informational purposes only and should not be regarded as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy the products or securities to which it applies. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided.

The information provided does not constitute investment advice nor take into account the individual financial circumstances or objectives of any investor. Any information that may be provided relating to past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results or performance.

To the extent permitted by law, in no event shall Capital.com (or any affiliate or employee) have any liability for any loss arising from the use of the information provided. Any person acting on the information does so entirely at their own risk.

Any information which could be construed as “investment research” has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is considered to be a marketing communication.