AUTO FILE-Is limiting 'Made in Europe' to the EU a blow to the auto sector?

By Reuters News

By Nick Carey

- Greetings from London! The European Union and Britain hold a summit this Friday and top of the agenda is 'Made in Europe', or the local content rules that are intended to force the Chinese to produce EVs within the bloc.

But the rules leave out Britain, Turkey, Morocco and others that are part of Europe’s automotive ecosystem.

Automakers with operations in those countries argue that rather than helping Europe, cutting those countries out will cause widespread harm instead.

Which brings us to today’s Auto File…

  • What qualifies as Europe?

  • Can you invest in Germany’s auto sector?

  • The race for India’s luxury car buyers

European self-harm?

Taken at face value, ‘Made in Europe’ sounds like just what the EU needs.

China’s automakers are gaining share at an unprecedented pace, hitting 10.7% of the market in the second quarter.

To put that in perspective, Japan’s automakers have around the same share in Europe. But what has sent shock waves across the continent’s auto industry is that while it took the Japanese about four decades to amass that kind of share, the Chinese have done it in about three years.

Traditional automakers argue that forcing the Chinese to produce in the EU with the same cost base would allow local players to compete, while they don’t stand a chance against cars imported from China.

But some in the bloc want to define ‘Made in Europe” as just the EU – excluding Britain, Turkey, Morocco and others. Auto executives say that’s where the problem begins.

I spoke about this today with Jim Baumbick, Ford’s president in Europe, and he described shutting out other markets as “the definition of self-harm.”

You can read about that here.


Changing ground rules

Baumbick’s key point is that like other traditional automakers, Ford has invested billions of dollars using today’s ground rules.

The US automaker’s engineers in Britain and Germany have designed the one-ton Transit van – long Europe’s top-selling van in that segment. Ford then uses engines and EV motors plus parts from suppliers in the EU to sell the van across Europe.

This all uses a supply chain that has developed gradually over decades using today’s ground rules.

Ford says that more than 50% of the Transit’s parts are provided by suppliers based in the EU and over 30% from Britain and Turkey.

“We've made massive investments,” Baumbick told me. “But I can't keep making investments for my company if I have to turn around and address the cost because the rules of the game have changed.”

This is the argument that Britain, Turkey and Morocco are also making for being included in ‘Made in Europe.’

Turkey, for instance, argues that shared automotive supply chains support over 250,000 jobs in the EU.  Britain’s car lobby and its EU equivalent the ACEA say cutting the UK out threatens a trade relationship worth $88 billion annually.


'Fair playing field'

Beyond the thorny subject of which countries to include in the EU’s definition of Europe, Baumbick is all for ‘Made in Europe.’

He makes a similar argument to that of Renault CEO Francois Provost.

Provost says he can’t compete with the 30% to 40% cost advantage Chinese automakers enjoy when they import cars into Europe but says he’s happy to compete against the Chinese if they are forced to produce locally.

“We're trying to compete with China,” Baumbick says. “But does that mean that China can invest in Europe? Sure.”

Baumbick uses a football – sorry, soccer for the non-Europeans out there – analogy for having the Chinese build cars in Europe, which would equate to having “11 men or women on one side and 11 men or women on the other side.”

Meanwhile, as we’ve noted before, Chinese automakers are not waiting for the EU to decide what’s Europe and what’s not, they’re already moving ahead with plans to make cars that will qualify for ‘Made in Europe’ from day one.

Recommended reading:

  • Global EV sales rose in October

  • Nvidia rules out Huang comeback

  • GM goes for more robots

German ups and downs

It’s been a week of striking contrasts for Germany’s auto sector.

First, there was the nice scoop from Reuters colleague Ilona Wissenbach that Mercedes-Benz is halting all investments in its German plants and exploring factory ‌closures to tackle the high cost of car manufacturing in its home country.

"We all want to avoid plant closures at all costs,” management board member ​Britta Seeger said in a memo seen by Reuters. “Unfortunately, however, we must now explore this option in more detail.”

You can read all about that here.

It’s the same refrain we’ve heard from Volkswagen, that Germany’s labor and energy costs are simply way too high, forcing the world’s No. 2 automaker by sales into its biggest ever restructuring.

Major German supplier Schaeffler is also slashing jobs and closing sites in Germany, citing weak demand for combustion-engine autos.

And yet this week Tesla announced a $3.3 billion investment in its German factory outside Berlin to start making Cybercabs.

What Tesla has in mind could make its factory in Gruenheide the largest car plant in Germany.

No doubt Germany’s powerful IG Metall union will have noticed the disconnect and it could come up in tough labor talks with German automakers in the weeks ahead.

India’s premium race

Global automakers are racing to get a foothold in India’s luxury car market.

As Reuters colleague Aditi Shah reports, during the last week, China’s BYD launched its luxury Denza brand in India, followed closely by an announcement from BMW that it will launch its Alpina brand there next year.

India’s luxury car market is tiny today. It accounted for just 1% of sales last year but is expected to grow to 5% by 2030.

Luxury European brands have taken a beating in China, so any new market with growth potential is a natural choice for them.

And India is a lure for the Chinese even though it has strict investment rules for countries sharing its land ⁠border, which have ​restricted BYD and its rivals from bringing money into the ​country to build a factory.

India also imposes ​tariffs of up to 100% on Chinese vehicles.

China’s automakers are so keen to get a foothold in India’s market that they will try to sell there even if they lack the cost advantage they enjoy elsewhere.

FAST LAPS

The United Auto Workers union urged top US lawmakers to keep the House China ​Select Committee in place when Democrats take over, citing concerns about Chinese ‌automakers, according to a letter seen by Reuters.

​Volkswagen's EV joint venture in China has not planned any new models for 2027 or 2028, two people with knowledge ​of the situation said, after its ID. UNYX series failed to meet sales expectations.

Italian sports car maker Lamborghini said the US-Iran war is no longer ​disrupting deliveries to the region, but the Volkswagen-owned ‌luxury brand warned that the outlook remained highly uncertain.

Tesla said it was inviting select customers to buy the Cybercab for personal use, marking a push towards delivering fully- designed autonomous vehicles to customers.

Renault ​plans to hire 2,000 staff at its French plants by 2028 to ‌meet EV demand, while shedding up to 1,000 white-collar jobs through voluntary departures.

Stark Future has become the first electric motorcycle company in Europe to reach unicorn ​status after raising at least €150 million in equity and now plans to expand into larger ‌motorcycle categories, its founder told Reuters.

Think your friend or colleague should know about us? Forward this newsletter to them. They can also subscribe here.

Capital.com is an execution-only brokerage platform and the content provided on the Capital.com website is intended for informational purposes only and should not be regarded as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy the products or securities to which it applies. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided.

The information provided does not constitute investment advice nor take into account the individual financial circumstances or objectives of any investor. Any information that may be provided relating to past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results or performance.

To the extent permitted by law, in no event shall Capital.com (or any affiliate or employee) have any liability for any loss arising from the use of the information provided. Any person acting on the information does so entirely at their own risk.

Any information which could be construed as “investment research” has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is considered to be a marketing communication.