Lawyers in Google Play case reduce fee bid to $78 million after judge’s criticism
By Mike Scarcella
WASHINGTON, Nov 16 (Reuters) - Lawyers who helped negotiate a $630 million consumer settlement with Alphabet’s Google over its Play Store have renewed their bid for legal fees, asking a federal judge in California to award them $78.6 million after he questioned whether their work justified a larger amount they sought.
Here are the details:
The lead consumer attorneys, Karma Giulianelli of Bartlit Beck and Hae Sung Nam of Kaplan Fox & Kilsheimer, in a filing on Friday said their request for $78,625,000 is justified based on their contributions to the litigation and nationwide settlement.
They reduced their request by 7.5%, or $6,375,000, after US District Judge James Donato last month questioned the adequacy of the plaintiffs’ billing records and the scope of their role obtaining the settlement. “Every state and equivalent entity in the Union had attorneys who participated in the litigation leading to the settlement,” Donato wrote.
The lawyers said they played a significant role in the case before states joined the litigation, and that no state objected to their fee request.
Google allegedly overcharged Play Store customers through restrictions on app distribution on Android devices and fees for in-app transactions. The company agreed in 2023 to pay $630 million into a consumer settlement fund and $70 million into a separate fund managed by states. Google denied wrongdoing.
The consumer case was once a class action, but Donato decertified it after he ruled that the plaintiffs could not rely on key testimony from an economist. The plaintiffs' reduced fee request accounts for work performed on class certification matters.
The case is In re Google Play Store Antitrust Litigation, US District Court, Northern District of California, No. 3:21-md-02981-JD.
For consumer plaintiffs: Karma Giulianelli of Bartlit Beck, and Hae Sung Nam of Kaplan Fox & Kilsheimer
For Google: Glenn Pomerantz of Munger, Tolles & Olson; Jonathan Kravis of Liu Shur Kravis; and Brian Rocca of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius
Read more:
US judge rebuffs $85 million fee request by lawyers in Google Play antitrust litigation
Judge calls $3,000 hourly rate 'patently unreasonable' as lawyer billing soars
Judge in Google privacy class action awards lawyers $147 million in legal fees