Switzerland house price crash: Swiss National Bank’s aggressive rate hikes will test market’s resilience from Zurich to Geneva and beyond
A booming Swiss housing market was at the crossroads following the Swiss National Bank’s decision to take interest rates out of negative territory for the first time in 15 years.
Economists have warned of formations of property bubbles in Zurich and Geneva due to “excessive dependence of housing prices on low interest rates”. Although privately-owned apartments continued to report price appreciation for the 11th quarter in a row in September 2022.
It remains to be seen how the Swiss real estate market reacts when the effects of rising interest rates begin to take hold.
Is a Swiss housing price crash imminent? Let’s find out below.
What is a housing crash?
A housing market crash is a period of sharp drop in real estate prices and activities. It is typically preceded by a housing bubble, during which property prices soar, often aided by low interest rates and speculative interests.
Housing markets have historically undergone cycles of peaks and troughs. The factors that lead to such periods of boom and bust include supply and demand, interest rate changes and government regulations, among other things.
In 2007, the US experienced a subprime mortgage crisis which was triggered by excessive borrowing at low-interest rates by under-funded borrowers. The overflowing liquidity in the market and increased property demand led to a speculative housing bubble.
As borrowers began defaulting on their mortgages, foreclosures increased, mortgage-linked securities held by banks crashed and property prices dropped. These events ultimately led to the financial crisis of 2007-2008.
What is your sentiment on USD/CHF?
History of housing crashes in Switzerland
Historical data on Switzerland real estate market compiled by data firm Trading Economics revealed that housing prices have trended upwards over the last 50 years.
According to the Swiss National Bank (SNB), real estate wealth in the nation has more than doubled, from CHF942bn ($995.96bn) in 2000 to CHF2.212trn in 2020.
However, there have been periods of crashes in the housing market in Switzerland, with historical data revealing a slump in the Switzerland Residential House Price index in the mid-1970s and in the 1990s.
Most notably, the collapse of the Switzerland housing market in the 1990s was mainly attributable to a Swiss banking crisis, high interest rates and weak economic growth over the decade.
The real estate crisis of the 1990s had succeeded a property boom of the 1980s that saw housing prices grow at an annual rate of more than 10%.
The Switzerland property market rebounded strongly in the 2000s due to a variety of factors, including tight housing supply, increased institutional real estate investment, higher immigration rates and rise in mortgage loans.
The introduction of a negative interest rate regime in late 2014 further fuelled a prolonged housing market boom in Switzerland. The nation’s central bank took it a step further in January 2015 as it cut interest rates in Switzerland to a record low of -0.75%.
The record low interest rates were held between January 2015 to June 2022.
Between early 2000 and mid 2022, the real estate price index for privately-owned apartments rose over 150%.
Is a Switzerland house price crash imminent?
The latest Switzerland property news warned of a formation of a housing bubble in the Alpine nation. The residential property price index of privately-owned apartments rose for the 11th quarter in a row in the Q3 2022.
Meanwhile, the price-to-rent ratio in Switzerland increased to 126 in September 2022, data compiled by Trading Economics showed, compared to an average of 98 from 1970 to 2022.
The price-to-rent ratio is a measure of real estate valuation. The latest above average figures for Switzerland pointed to a formation of a Switzerland housing bubble. Fritz Zurbrügg, vice chairman of the Governing Board at SNB said:
The Swiss real estate market’s resilience could be tested as central banks across the world hike interest rates at an unprecedented pace to tame multi-decade high inflation.
The SNB hiked rates for the first time in 15 years in June 2022, increasing rates by 50 basis point (bps) to -0.25%. In September 2022, the Swiss central bank followed up with a 75 bps hike to take interest rates into positive territory for the first time since late 2014.
As of 25 November 2022, Switzerland interest rates stood at 0.5%.
Zurich, Switzerland’s largest city, ranked third in the UBS Global Real Estate Bubble Index, which listed global metropolitans with housing markets that are “highly elevated” with prices “out of sync with rising interest rates”.
Only Toronto and Frankfurt ranked above Zurich in the “bubble risk zone” that included some of the biggest cities in the world, including Hong Kong, Munich, Amsterdam and Tokyo.
Geneva, Switzerland’s second-most populated city, ranked 15th on the UBS Global Real Estate Bubble Index and was ranked “overvalued”.
“For Zurich, the combination of negative interest rates and strong economic and population growth have triggered excessive price increases over the last few years. The price-to-rent ratio has reached elevated levels that are out of sync with interest rates firmly in positive territory.
“This holds for Geneva, too, although the city has lagged behind Zurich both in terms of price and population growth as people move to more affordable regions. However, the housing shortage will likely persist, as the building applications for new apartments have fallen to the lowest level in over a decade.”
Swiss housing market predictions for 2022 and beyond
The possibility of a Swiss house price crash is largely dependent on the monetary policy of the nation’s central bank, which in turn is dependent on inflation.
The outlook of the Russia-Ukraine war is among the key events that policy makers will be monitoring to judge the course of price pressures.
The SNB will be wary of mortgage and real estate markets when framing its monetary policy, given that mortgages accounted for 95% of the total household liabilities at the end of 2020.
Economists at ING Think expected the SNB to hike rates by another 75 bps in December 2022 and could leave rates at 1.25% for the whole of 2023.
It remains to be seen how Switzerland’s housing market reacts to elevated interest rates after years of cheap liquidity.
Final thoughts
Forecasting housing market crashes is a challenging task due to the unknowns of the future. Therefore, it is important to note that analysts and experts can be wrong in their Swiss housing market predictions.
Forecasts shouldn’t be used as a substitute for your own research. Always conduct your own due diligence. Remember that your decision to trade or invest should depend on your risk tolerance, expertise in the market, portfolio size, and goals. Keep in mind that past performance is no guarantee of future results. And never trade money that you cannot afford to lose.
FAQ
Does Switzerland have a housing crisis?
The Swiss housing market is showing signs of a property bubble. The residential property price index of privately-owned apartments rose for the 11th quarter in a row in the third quarter of 2022.
With the Swiss National Bank taking interest rates to positive territory for the first time in 15 years, it remains to be seen if the Swiss housing market can remain resilient.
Is there a housing bubble in Switzerland?
According to UBS, the price-to-rent ratio in Zurich and Geneva are among the highest in the world.
Is now a good time to buy a property in Switzerland?
If you are interested in investing in the Swiss real estate market it is important to conduct your own due diligence before investing.
Forecasting housing market crashes is a challenging task due to the unknowns of the future. Therefore, it is important to note that analysts and experts can be wrong in their Swiss housing market predictions.
Keep in mind that past performance is no guarantee of future results. And never trade money that you cannot afford to lose.
Related topics
